Google’s Silent Traffic Thief and the Controls You Have
%20(1).jpg)
Published:
October 31, 2025
Updated:
November 20, 2026
In August 2026, researchers at the University of Pennsylvania and Northeastern University posted a preregistered experiment, not yet peer reviewed, that altered Search for 1,100 US users for a week. Those switched to AI Mode clicked through to outside websites 18.8 percentage points less often than people on standard Google. An earlier randomized study from the Indian School of Business and Carnegie Mellon, also unreviewed, found AI Overviews cut outbound organic clicks by 38% on searches where they appeared.
Our breakdown of the search traffic drop covers which pages lose those clicks. This post asks who decides whether your page feeds the answer. Through 2025, the documented ways out of AI Overviews, short of leaving Search, also shrank or stripped your ordinary snippets. In 2026, a US court, regulators and Google each answered differently.
A US court found no deal, a UK regulator ordered an exit
Penske Media sued Google in September 2025, alleging it uses its search dominance to make feeding AI summaries the price of being listed. Chegg made similar claims. At the end of September 2026, Judge Amit Mehta dismissed their claims, writing that “an expectation is not an agreement.” The Penske dismissal was without prejudice, and both companies are appealing.
On June 3, 2026, Britain’s Competition and Markets Authority required Google to let publishers stop their content powering AI features such as AI Overviews, and to credit it with clear links, within nine months. The European Commission opened an investigation in December 2025 into Google’s use of publishers’ content for AI Overviews and AI Mode, including whether publishers can refuse “without losing access to Google Search,” and on October 29, 2026, five French publisher groups announced a complaint feeding it. This summarizes filings and decisions; it is not legal advice.
What each control removes, and what it costs
Google first tested the control with UK sites; since August 31, 2026, every website has a Search generative AI control in Search Console. Four levers, per Google’s documentation:
- The Search Console control removes a whole property from AI Overviews, AI Mode and generative AI in Discover, including as grounding. Google says it is not a ranking signal elsewhere, but you lose all traffic and impressions from those features, and AI training is unaffected.
- The nosnippet rule works per page. It stops the page being a direct input to AI Overviews and AI Mode, and strips its snippet from ordinary results too.
- The max-snippet rule caps snippet length and how much of the page can feed AI Overviews and AI Mode. At zero, it equals nosnippet.
- Google-Extended covers Gemini training and grounding in Gemini Apps and Vertex AI. It does not affect inclusion in Google Search, so it is not the switch for AI Overviews.
Protect the pages whose value is the answer
You decide with little data. Search Console’s generative AI report shows impressions but no clicks or queries. When Cyrus Shepard opted one site out, its AI impressions fell to zero and its regular organic clicks dropped too. One site proves little, but the exit may not be free.
A sensible way to sort pages is by where their value sits. If the answer is the product (a definition, a table, a figure you published), a summary can replace the visit, so test nosnippet, or data-nosnippet on the passages that carry it. If the value is the next step (a booking, a quote form), a citation works as a referral, and earning AI citations matters more than hiding. Test a dozen pages against a matched dozen for four to six weeks, counting clicks per page, not the “relevant traffic” totals of vague SEO reports.
Pages built on data only you hold are the hardest to summarize away, the case for original, data-led content. Run a page-by-page SEO review before touching the site-wide switch. The click was never yours to keep; it was Google’s to give. What 2026 changed is that you can refuse more of what Google takes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I opt out of AI Overviews without hurting my rankings?
Google says the Search Console control is not used as a ranking or inclusion signal elsewhere in Search, so ordinary listings should hold. You give up every impression and click from AI Overviews, AI Mode and generative AI in Discover. One single-site test saw regular organic clicks fall after opting out, so treat “no ranking effect” and “no traffic effect” as separate claims.
Does blocking Google-Extended keep my content out of AI Overviews?
No. Google-Extended is a robots.txt token for Gemini training and grounding in Gemini Apps and Vertex AI, and Google says it does not affect a site’s inclusion in Google Search. AI Overviews and AI Mode sit inside Search, so the snippet rules and the Search Console control govern them. The reverse holds too: that control does not stop AI training. Sites that want out of both need both.
What is the difference between nosnippet and the Search Console AI control?
Scope and side effects. The nosnippet rule is set per page and removes the text snippet from ordinary results as well as keeping the page out of AI Overviews and AI Mode as a direct input. The Search Console control works per property and removes the site from generative AI features only, leaving ordinary snippets alone. Use nosnippet for a few pages and the control for a whole site or section.
Did the publisher lawsuits against AI Overviews succeed?
Not so far. Judge Amit Mehta dismissed the antitrust suits by Penske Media and Chegg at the end of September 2026, finding, among other grounds, that they had not plausibly alleged an agreement with Google. Both companies are appealing. In Britain the CMA required an opt-out, and the European Commission’s investigation continues. This is a summary of filings and rulings, not legal advice.



