Should Retailers Block AI Shopping Agents? Four Stances
%20(3).jpg)
Published:
October 28, 2025
Updated:
November 5, 2026
On August 4, 2026, a US appeals court lifted the order that had stopped Perplexity’s Comet browser agent from shopping on Amazon. Amazon argued the agent accessed customer accounts without permission, but the Ninth Circuit found Amazon unlikely to win its anti-hacking claims because “It is the user who ‘accesses’ Amazon’s computers,” not Perplexity (Ninth Circuit). The judges said they were not establishing “a new legal regime governing agentic AI,” and on September 10 the full court declined to rehear the case.
For retailers, the ruling raises the cost of shutting AI agents out. In October 2025, three Bain partners set out in Harvard Business Review how brands must “decide whether to block, partner with, or build for these new intermediaries.” Here are their four stances, each with a current case.
1. Fully closed
Amazon is the model. It restricts outside agents from its site while its own “Buy for Me” feature can buy on other brands’ sites, Bain reported in May 2026, and in September it began blocking Meta’s Muse shopping agent, citing its terms of use (Bloomberg). Closing keeps discovery and the sale in-house, and Amazon says its Rufus assistant helped generate nearly $12 billion in incremental annualized sales. But Amazon’s Greg Smith also joined the tech council of the Google-led Universal Commerce Protocol in April 2026 (UCP), and after the Comet ruling, blocking user-directed agents is mainly a technical and contractual job, not a legal certainty.
2. Passive open
Many retailers let agents in without doing much for them. Eligible Shopify stores are in this position by default: their products flow to AI channels through Shopify Catalog. In January, Wayfair was testing agent placement carefully and Home Depot kept its own assistant on its site. “We want to give customers the choice,” Wayfair chief technology officer Fiona Tan told The Drum. Both have since connected their catalogs to ChatGPT. The risk is that agents describe your prices, stock and returns from whatever data they find.
3. Partnership
Retailers sell through ChatGPT, Gemini and Copilot, though the form keeps changing. OpenAI says it is “moving away from a standalone Instant Checkout experience,” so purchases that start in ChatGPT finish on the merchant’s own site, with no fees (OpenAI). Walmart runs its own app inside ChatGPT. Google’s Universal Commerce Protocol lets approved merchants offer checkout in AI Mode and Gemini while remaining merchant of record (Google). Kroger is live with Google, and Urban Outfitters’ parent URBN with Microsoft Copilot. The risk is dependence on ranking and checkout systems you do not control.
4. Built for agents
The most ambitious stance is a site built for machines: a “headless” or bot version of a retailer’s website that gives it “speed and control over how other agents access its inventory,” as Bain puts it. We found no major retailer with a dedicated agent-only site. In 2026, the practical version is publishing structured catalogs through Google’s and OpenAI’s commerce protocols and Shopify Catalog.
How to decide, and first steps
Bain itself has since recommended a blend: build where you have an edge, partner where agents bring new customers, and protect what makes your own site worth visiting. The traffic is small but valuable. In late 2025, AI was up to 25% of referral traffic for some retailers but under 1% of total traffic, Bain and Similarweb found, and Adobe reported AI-referred visitors to US retail sites converted 48% better than other traffic in August 2026. Whatever the stance:
- Write a bot policy, not only a robots.txt. robots.txt controls crawlers such as GPTBot and OAI-SearchBot, but OpenAI says its rules “may not apply” to visits a user asks ChatGPT to make (OpenAI). Cover firewall rules and terms of service too.
- Fix product data. OpenAI’s feed needs nine fields, including price and availability, kept current.
- Measure agent traffic. Use GA4’s AI Assistant channel for referrals and server logs for agent visits.
Our posts on product data for AI agents, Walmart’s agent deals, ChatGPT recommendations and retail media go deeper. We build agent-ready catalogs and sites through our ecommerce marketing and web design work.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can retailers block AI shopping agents?
Partly. robots.txt stops declared crawlers such as GPTBot and OAI-SearchBot, but OpenAI says its rules may not apply to visits a user asks ChatGPT to make, and Google says its user-requested agent generally ignores them. Firewalls can filter agents that sign their requests. Legally, a US appeals court found in August 2026 that Amazon was unlikely to win its anti-hacking claim against Perplexity’s agent.
Is Amazon v. Perplexity over?
No. A district court blocked Perplexity’s Comet agent from shopping on Amazon in March 2026, and the Ninth Circuit lifted that order on August 4, 2026. The full appeals court declined to rehear it on September 10. Amazon has since filed an amended complaint in the district court, and Perplexity has moved to dismiss it, so the final outcome is open.
Can shoppers still buy inside ChatGPT?
Mostly not. OpenAI says it is moving away from a standalone Instant Checkout experience, so shoppers discover products in ChatGPT and complete purchases on the merchant’s site or app. OpenAI charges no fees on purchases that start in ChatGPT. Shopify and Etsy catalogs are already connected, and other merchants can apply with a product feed. ChatGPT shopping is limited to the US.
What is agent-to-agent commerce?
It is the term for AI agents completing the whole journey from research to checkout with little or no human clicking, often by talking to a retailer’s own systems. Harvard Business Review’s framework gives retailers four stances toward it: fully closed, passive open, partnership, and building a dedicated interface for agents. It is different from Google’s Agent2Agent protocol, which shares the A2A initials.



