The Dupe Crackdown: What Brands Have Won and Lost in Court
.jpg)
Published:
October 28, 2025
Updated:
November 19, 2026
Trader Joe’s told a federal court in Ohio that its frozen crustless sandwiches are “squircles,” not circles, and that their crimped edge keeps the filling in. In late August 2026, Judge John Adams let J.M. Smucker’s Uncrustables lawsuit proceed, citing 20 years of brand building. Whether the crimp is functional, and so free to copy, is still open.
Five weeks later, UGG’s owner Deckers appealed a judgment in Quince’s favor. That is where the dupe crackdown stands in November 2026. This article reports filings and rulings; it is not legal advice.
The scorecard: who won, settled or lost
Smucker sued in October 2025 over the sandwich’s round shape, its crimp and its packaging. Nerds maker Ferrara sued the sellers of Dweebs over a name, mascots and logo that echo Nerds packaging, and in July 2026 obtained a stipulated permanent injunction against one distributor. Lululemon sued Costco in June 2025, stacking trade dress, word marks and design patents. Settlements through May 2026 left only a men’s zip-up jacket in dispute, and the case ended in August 2026 on undisclosed terms, with no ruling on the merits.
The losses teach more. A court held UGG’s boot trade dress generic, and in June 2026 a jury found Quince’s boot infringed Deckers’ design patent but found the patent invalid. In March 2026 a federal court in New York ruled the jar, colors and lettering of Sol de Janeiro’s Bum Bum Cream functional. And Benefit lost in December 2024 when the judge found Benefit had not shown that e.l.f. Cosmetics’ Lash ’N Roll mascara, “while it is a ‘dupe’ of Roller Lash,” actually dupes any consumers.
Why looking alike is not enough in court
A counterfeit copies the logo. A dupe copies the look, drops the logo and advertises the lower price. That pushes the fight into trade dress. The Supreme Court held in 2000 that design, “like color, is not inherently distinctive,” so a brand must prove shoppers already link the design to it, and that the feature is nonfunctional, not generic and likely to confuse.
Each loss failed a test. In the mascara case, $6 against $29, a different brand name on the box, more than 2.1 million units sold without evidence of confusion, and no survey of Benefit’s own all pointed one way. The UGG ruling is the legal form of how category codes erase a brand: what a whole category uses, nobody owns.
What to file before the dupe arrives
A sensible order, offered as advice: register product and color names, which are cheap to protect; build evidence for a shape early; file design patents for new designs; and enroll in Amazon Brand Registry, which is free, requires a registered or pending trademark and gives you its Report a Violation tool. Courts are the last step of a brand protection program, not the first.
When the lawsuit becomes the headline
Suing puts your own rights on trial. Lululemon settled with manufacturer Jacques Moret amid Moret’s bid to cancel two Lululemon design patents. Quince sued Deckers in February 2026, alleging “hundreds of sham trade dress lawsuits,” and sought about $1.8 million in fees and costs in the boot case. The antitrust complaint was dismissed with leave to amend in August 2026. A loss also puts “generic” or “functional” beside your product in a public ruling.
Or compete on what a dupe cannot copy
In an October 2023 Morning Consult poll of 2,216 US adults, 31% had intentionally bought a dupe of a premium product, and about 49% of Gen Z had. No court will stop these value-seeking shoppers who broke fashion’s old customer rules. Give them reasons to pay more that a lookalike cannot carry: fit, fabric, guarantees, repair. The founders in the Fenty to SKIMS lessons built that on consistent codes, and a distinct brand identity makes a copy look like a copy.
Courts protect what shoppers already connect to you. Everything else is open to copying, so protection starts years before the lawsuit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it legal to sell a dupe?
Often it is. A brand protection attorney told Glossy in 2025 that dupes “may not be illegal on their own”. A dupe crosses the line when it infringes a trademark, protected trade dress or a patent, or when its advertising misleads buyers. Counterfeits differ because they carry the original’s logo. Each case turns on its facts, so ask a trademark lawyer about yours.
Can I trademark the shape of my product?
Sometimes, but rarely at launch. Under Wal-Mart v. Samara, product design qualifies only after it acquires secondary meaning, so shoppers must already link it to you. It also cannot be functional, like Sol de Janeiro’s jar, or generic, like UGG’s boots. Packaging is easier because it may be inherently distinctive. Keep evidence from day one: sales, ad spend, press naming the design and a consumer survey.
Will Amazon take down a dupe of my product?
Only if it infringes a right you can show. Brand Registry requires a registered or pending trademark, and Report a Violation is for reporting infringement. A listing that copies your look without your name or logo gives you less to report than a counterfeit does. Register brand and product names first, patent new designs, and keep dated records of when you created each one.
Should a smaller brand sue a big retailer over a dupe?
Only after a hard look at your own rights, because a suit invites attacks on them. Lululemon faced a bid to cancel two design patents, and Deckers’ trade dress was held generic and its patent invalid, a result it is appealing. Defendants can also counterclaim or seek fees, as Quince did. A reasonable test before filing is whether you hold registered rights and evidence of real confusion.



