Why Some Brands Are Rejecting AI, and What the Promise Costs
%20(16).jpg)
Published:
October 25, 2025
Updated:
October 19, 2026
In July 2026 a certification called the Human Made Mark began accepting adverts. To earn it, a producer uploads call sheets, behind-the-scenes photos and credits, signs a legal declaration that, in founder William Grave’s words, “no human artists were replaced by generative AI,” and pays 0.25% of the production budget, LBB reported.
A label like this has a market because a few brands have made “no AI” part of what they sell. The clearest is Aerie, owned by American Eagle Outfitters. On October 9, 2025, it posted on Instagram, Business Insider reported: “Today we commit: No AI-generated bodies or people. Real people only.” In March 2026 it repeated the promise in a Pamela Anderson film that ends with her line “You can’t prompt this,” Marketing Dive reported. Aerie’s comparable sales rose 25% in the fiscal first quarter of 2026 and 19% in the second, and the company credited “the continued relevance of the ‘100% Aerie REAL’ campaign” in its first-quarter results. It also raised advertising spending, so the pledge’s own effect can’t be isolated.
Who has promised what
The formal promises are narrow:
- Aerie rules out AI-generated people and bodies, including in work by its creators and agencies, but uses AI for media buying and analytics. “We’re not resisting AI,” chief marketing officer Stacey McCormick told Glossy.
- Dove pledged in April 2024 “to not use artificial intelligence (AI) to represent women in its advertising and communications,” Marketing Dive reported.
- iHeartMedia made “Guaranteed Human” part of its on-air branding in November 2025. “We don’t use AI-generated personalities,” said Tom Poleman of iHeartMedia, Inside Radio reported.
An earlier version of this post grouped Heineken and Polaroid with Aerie, which overstated both. Heineken’s October 2025 US campaign mocked AI “friend” wearables with the line “The best way to make a friend is over a beer,” LBB reported. It was about AI companionship, not how ads are made; Heineken’s 2026 agency setup also supports an AI program, Marketing Dive reported. Polaroid’s 2025 billboards said “AI can’t generate sand between your toes,” but of its 2026 follow-up, creative director Patricia Varella told eMarketer: “It’s not a campaign against AI or against data centers.”
Why the promise can work
In a Gartner survey of 1,539 US consumers published in March 2026, 50% said they would prefer to give their business to brands that don’t use generative AI in consumer-facing content. In a 2024 NielsenIQ study, people found AI-generated ads more “annoying,” “boring” and “confusing” than traditional ads, and brain readings showed weaker memory activation. In December 2025 McDonald’s Netherlands withdrew an AI-generated Christmas ad after a backlash, The Drum reported.
The promise works best when it extends something the brand already stands for. Aerie has refused to retouch its models since 2014; Dove has built its advertising on real women since 2004.
What the promise commits you to
- Tools and stock. Photoshop has built-in generative features, and Adobe Stock accepts AI-generated images if they are labeled.
- Suppliers. Retouchers, production companies, creators and agencies need the same rule in their contracts.
- Ad platforms. In June 2026 REI pulled an Instagram ad after a Meta AI tool it had been automatically enrolled in altered a supplier’s photo, TechSpot reported.
- Records. Keep call sheets, raw files and credits, so you can show who made the work.
The risks
The first is breaking the promise by accident. In 2024 Wizards of the Coast denied that a marketing image used AI, then admitted it had and blamed a vendor, Vice reported. The second is false accusation: in January 2026 Nintendo had to deny fan claims that its promotional photos were AI-generated.
For the other side, see our pieces on Mondelez’s AI spending, Oreo’s AI ads and why human copy wins back ground. Deciding where AI fits, and what to promise customers, is part of our brand identity strategy and content marketing work.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which brands have promised not to use AI in their ads?
The clearest case is Aerie, which committed in October 2025 to “No AI-generated bodies or people” and repeated it in March 2026. Dove pledged in 2024 not to use AI to represent women in its ads, and iHeartMedia brands its stations “Guaranteed Human.” Each promise is narrow: Aerie and iHeartMedia still use AI for tasks such as media buying, analytics and scheduling, and Unilever uses AI-assisted product imagery for Dove.
Is Heineken against AI in advertising?
No. Heineken’s October 2025 US campaign mocked AI “friend” wearables and encouraged people to meet over a beer, but it made no promise to keep AI out of its ads. It invests in AI marketing: it opened a generative AI lab in 2025 whose remit includes creating marketing content, and in 2026 it consolidated its agency roster, a move that also supports an AI program called Freddy AI.
Do brands have to label AI-generated ads?
In some places. New York has required ads to disclose AI-generated synthetic performers since June 9, 2026, when the advertiser knows they are used, Cooley notes. In the EU, the AI Act has required deepfakes to be disclosed since August 2, 2026, with lighter rules for clearly artistic or satirical work. Rules elsewhere vary: China, for example, has required labels on AI-generated content since September 1, 2025.
Should a small brand promise not to use AI?
Only if it can keep the promise and it fits what the brand already stands for. Write the pledge narrowly, for example no AI-generated people, and put the same rule in contracts with photographers, retouchers, creators and agencies. Switch off automatic creative features in ad platforms and keep production records. A promise broken by accident, as Wizards of the Coast found in 2024, can do more damage than no promise.



